College comparison

Carroll College vs University of Providence: cost, debt and earnings compared

University of Providence is cheaper, with a net price $4,803 a year lower. Carroll College graduates earn more: $66,371 versus $51,419 ten years after starting. On payback time, Carroll College is the better deal for the money.

Carroll CollegeHelena, MontanaUniversity of ProvidenceGreat Falls, Montana
Net price per year$26,295$21,492
Sticker cost per year$56,907$45,423
Median debt at graduation$21,500$19,500
Monthly loan payment$244$222
Earnings 1 year after graduating$50,631$70,599
Earnings 6 years after starting$54,426$46,199
Earnings 10 years after starting$66,371$51,419
Graduation rate68%28%
Students who return for year 282%72%
Acceptance rate71%50%
Average SAT1200980
Undergraduates1,092528
Years to pay back the full cost3.1 years4.4 years

Green marks the better number. Net price is the average paid after grants. Earnings are medians for former students who received federal aid.

Carroll College

Good value

The full net price is about $105,180 (4 years at $26,295). Former students earn $66,371 ten years after starting, about $34,371 a year more than a typical high-school graduate. That pays back the cost in roughly 3.1 years.

University of Providence

Fair value

The full net price is about $85,968 (4 years at $21,492). Former students earn $51,419 ten years after starting, about $19,419 a year more than a typical high-school graduate. That pays back the cost in roughly 4.4 years.

Hiring?

Can we recruit this person for you in the Philippines, Vietnam or Colombia?

In the US, graduates of Carroll College and University of Providence earn a median of $66,371 a year. You can hire people with the same degree and skills abroad for a fraction of that, and they work full time, on your hours, only for you.

  • We source and screen candidates in 15 countries, from Manila and Ho Chi Minh City to Bogota and Mexico City
  • You interview the shortlist and only pay when you hire
  • We can run contracts, payroll and equipment, so you get one simple monthly invoice
Hire fromTypical all-in cost
Philippines$13k to $23k / year
Vietnam$13k to $23k / year
Colombia$20k to $33k / year
Mexico$23k to $37k / year
India$13k to $23k / year

Rough planning estimates based on local senior-level pay plus recruiting and payroll. Your real quote depends on role and seniority.

Tell us who you need

Free and no obligation. We reply within one business day.